Sunday, October 17, 2021
News for Retirees

Rising Medicare Annual Wellness Visits in Accountable Care Organizations

Share this…FacebookPinterestTwitterLinkedin Am J Accountable Care. 2021;9(3):13-18. _____ In 2011, Medicare launched the annual wellness go to (AWV) to…

By Staff , in Medicare , at September 15, 2021

Am J Accountable Care. 2021;9(3):13-18.


In 2011, Medicare launched the annual wellness go to (AWV) to broaden protection of preventive well being companies to older adults. The go to gives a chance for suppliers to give attention to facets of preventive care (eg, evidence-based screening companies, customized well being threat assessments, advance care planning) which will usually be neglected throughout acute downside–primarily based visits due to time constraints or extra urgent well being issues. For AWVs, sufferers owe no co-pay and clinicians are reimbursed at a excessive fee.1

CMS requires that sure components be addressed at every AWV. Sufferers and suppliers work to create a customized prevention plan, which incorporates age-appropriate preventive companies, cognitive screening, customized well being recommendation to establish and work to mitigate threat elements, and the implementation of suggestions from the US Preventive Companies Job Drive and the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices.2 Ideally, the AWV affords the chance for early illness detection and downstream mitigation of illness results, bettering affected person outcomes and decreasing general prices.

Though the general utility of annual preventive visits in reaching these goals has been debated,3 the comparatively latest adoption of the AWV renders any definitive conclusions relating to its effectiveness untimely. Some research have proven associations between the AWV and elevated utilization of preventive care companies. One research indicated that the AWV is related to considerably larger odds of present process mammography, Pap exams, bone mass measurement, and prostate and colon most cancers screening, in addition to acquiring the influenza vaccine.4 One other research confirmed that sufferers who had an AWV had elevated testing for doable causes of cognitive impairment (eg, thyrotropin, B12) relative to these with out an AWV.5 Further work has demonstrated that Medicare beneficiaries who make the most of AWVs have larger pneumococcal vaccination and influenza vaccination charges than those that don’t,6 and one other research equally demonstrated that sufferers who had an AWV had a better proportion of influenza vaccination, despair screening, and sexually transmitted an infection screening than those that didn’t.7 Nonetheless, one research advised that despair screening was low (10%) amongst sufferers who obtain AWVs and was not considerably completely different from these with non-AWV visits.8

Though research have proven will increase in utilization of sure preventive companies amongst AWV attendees, few research have assessed the consequences of the AWV on prices, and the present research present combined outcomes. One research demonstrated {that a} first-time AWV was related to a 5.7% discount in complete well being care prices within the 11 months following the AWV, estimating a per-member per-month lower of $81 in general spending.9 Of observe, sufferers within the highest-risk hierarchical situation class (HCC) quartile had the best discount in prices for these attending an AWV relative to those that didn’t. One other research confirmed that AWV customers had a major discount in complete well being care spending ($162) at 24 months following an AWV relative to matched beneficiaries who didn’t obtain an AWV,10 and a case report famous that growing the proportion of its sufferers attending an AWV was related to general reductions in well being care prices.11 Nonetheless, one other massive research evaluating outcomes in practices that adopted the AWV vs those who didn’t discovered no constant proof of associations between AWV use and spending, emergency division visits, or hospitalizations.3 One other research discovered that AWV charges weren’t correlated with Medicare spending.12

Nonetheless, the prospect of ultimately realizing decreases in well being care prices by prioritizing preventive well being has led Medicare to incentivize practices to include the AWV, leading to alternatives for accountable care organizations (ACOs) to extend income whereas offering this service to sufferers. Medicare covers AWVs at 100%, attributing 2.43 relative worth items (RVUs) for preliminary AWVs and 1.5 RVUs for subsequent AWVs13; moreover, suppliers are in a position to invoice for diagnostic and remedy companies offered similtaneously the AWV, usually leading to higher income for these practices using the AWV (though these extra companies could require a affected person co-pay).14,15 The mandated construction of the go to additionally helps physicians to shut pay-for-performance high quality measure gaps, and ACOs taking part within the Medicare Shared Financial savings Program can fulfill high quality measures utilizing information collected on the AWV.16 The go to additionally gives the chance to make sure the accuracy of HCC-related diagnoses, which can end in larger risk-adjusted issue scores and related larger reimbursement charges for extra sophisticated, at-risk sufferers. The AWV additionally gives a further affected person care go to, which can enhance the steadiness of the beneficiary project to the follow conducting the go to.14 As could also be anticipated given these doable advantages, sufferers who’re attributed to an ACO have been proven to be extra prone to obtain an AWV than those that will not be.12

Regardless of the doable advantages to each suppliers and sufferers, adoption of the AWV has been modest, with an estimated 24% of eligible beneficiaries receiving an AWV in 2017,10 up from 7.5% in 2011.12 The big proportion of eligible beneficiaries not receiving an AWV presents a chance to extend the evidence-based preventive care companies offered to sufferers and notice extra income. Not many research exist exploring the consequences of interventions geared toward growing the proportion of beneficiaries receiving an AWV. A case research of Bellin Well being Companions described a 4-pronged method using a structured care staff (registered nurse–led AWVs), well being data know-how functions (together with work lists, compliance experiences, and care hole experiences), supplier incentives, and workers communication (contacting beneficiaries to schedule visits), which in the end led to a rise within the fee of AWVs amongst eligible beneficiaries.11 Aledade equally applied coaching classes and automatic work lists to assist small practices have interaction AWV-eligible beneficiaries.17 A small university-affiliated follow utilized a nursing care supervisor, in live performance with particular doctor suggestions, to extend the speed of AWVs amongst eligible sufferers.18 A 2008 systematic evaluate examined the consequences of assorted clinician interventions (computer-generated prompts and paper-based prompts) and affected person interventions (together with mailed reminder letters, phone notifications, flyers and posters directed towards sufferers, dwelling visitations encouraging vaccinations, and training to encourage return visits) on growing use of preventive care companies. Though it was performed previous to the implementation of AWVs, the research demonstrated general modest results of using prompts on elevated utilization of preventive companies, exhibiting common variations of 10% to 14%, relying on the prompting technique.19


BJC is an built-in well being system that operates a Medicare Shared Financial savings Program ACO, with roughly 150 main care suppliers caring for 34,728 beneficiaries in Illinois and Missouri. BJC recognized the AWV as a key alternative to enhance care supply and sought to extend the charges at which its attributed eligible beneficiaries acquired AWVs. BJC recognized 2 broad areas on which to focus its consideration: lowering boundaries to scheduling AWVs and growing the effectivity and comfort of conducting AWVs. BJC recognized obstacles inside each classes and applied the improvements outlined inside the following sections.

Rising Ease of Scheduling AWVs

C-SNAP entry for places of work. C-SNAP is a service offered by CMS that enables suppliers and workplace workers to view eligibility and declare standing data for Medicare beneficiaries. Medicare covers 1 AWV inside every 12-month interval for eligible beneficiaries. Provided that different suppliers (together with, at occasions, wellness vans20) could have already performed an AWV inside the prior 12-month interval, BJC suppliers could not know whether or not the AWV that they supply could be lined. BJC recognized this uncertainty relating to whether or not beneficiaries had already obtained an AWV as a doable barrier to offering AWVs. C-SNAP permits customers to evaluate whether or not beneficiaries have had an AWV performed with a supplier exterior the BJC system. BJC offered C-SNAP entry for each workplace to facilitate critiques of claims for beneficiaries and be certain that the AWV will not be duplicated.

Digital well being file monitoring. BJC makes use of the Epic digital well being file (EHR), which permits for identification and monitoring of pertinent well being upkeep information. BJC ACO and data know-how workers labored collectively so as to add a function to every affected person’s chart itemizing the date of the affected person’s final AWV and the date that the affected person could be eligible for his or her subsequent AWV. This was viewable by suppliers and workplace workers to help in scheduling sufferers for AWVs and figuring out sufferers who offered to clinic for an acute go to who had been additionally eligible for a concurrent AWV.

Eligible affected person lists. ACO workers created a claims database of all ACO members indicating the date of the members’ most up-to-date AWV (if any) and the date they had been eligible for his or her subsequent AWV. Particular person affected person lists had been despatched to every main care clinic, and every clinic proactively contacted sufferers who weren’t but scheduled for an AWV within the upcoming 12 months. If sufferers had been already scheduled (for a diabetes follow-up go to, for instance), clinic workers would attain out to the affected person relating to the potential for including an AWV on the similar go to. Though important guide efforts had been nonetheless required, this intervention offered readability relating to which sufferers had been eligible for AWVs and ensured that they had been scheduled at applicable occasions to restrict declare denials.

AWV monitoring dashboard. BJC developed dashboards permitting for the visualization of AWV charges by supplier, follow, and area. These dashboards allowed ACO management to research developments and allocate assets as wanted (eg, extra consideration could be given to areas with low AWV charges, and suppliers with larger AWV charges would possibly be capable of provide extra suggestions on efficient strategies).

Compensation bonus. To incentivize suppliers to handle remaining boundaries to scheduling and conducting AWVs, BJC permitted a 1% compensation bonus for any main care supplier who achieved an AWV fee of fifty% or higher amongst eligible ACO beneficiaries inside the supplier’s affected person panel. To assist suppliers monitor their progress, they got up to date AWV charges every month.

Rising Effectivity and Comfort of Conducting AWVs

BJC included the necessities of the AWV right into a standardized observe template within the Epic EHR to facilitate environment friendly entry of pertinent affected person well being data and cut back burden on clinicians. As has been demonstrated in different affected person populations, sufferers who obtain care at BJC usually had an absence of readability and understanding relating to the aim and contents of the AWV. BJC due to this fact created a written communication (eAppendix [available at]) to elucidate the aim and contents of an AWV to sufferers and reply continuously requested questions.

BJC additionally sought to additional streamline visits by starting information acquisition previous to the go to. A portion of the AWV includes the completion of the well being threat evaluation (HRA) questionnaire. To facilitate the environment friendly assortment of this data, BJC workers can ship the HRA questionnaire to the affected person earlier than the go to by way of a affected person portal; if the affected person completes this earlier than the go to, their responses will robotically populate the supplier observe.

To put a constant organizational groundwork, BJC moreover invested in webinar coaching classes to additional educate workers and suppliers on the aim, content material, and greatest practices of an AWV. BJC additional developed and disseminated a best-practice workflow amongst suppliers to standardize components of the AWV and provides suppliers a constant framework for conducting the go to. BJC additionally held in-person conferences with all member practices to speak pertinent background data relating to the AWV, clarify the interventions addressed herein, and supply the chance for suppliers to ask questions and provide suggestions.


In 2018, BJC performed AWVs for 44.3% of eligible attributed sufferers. BJC set a aim of conducting an AWV for 50% of eligible attributed beneficiaries in 2019 following the implementation of those interventions. BJC was in a position to exceed its aim, conducting AWVs for 69.7% of eligible sufferers in 2019. This locations BJC above the ninetieth percentile amongst ACOs taking part within the Medicare Shared Financial savings Program (Determine) (Institute for Accountable Care, e-mail communication, evaluation of 2019 Medicare claims information for 517 MSSP ACOs, March 19, 2021).

In complete, of the 129 main care suppliers who’ve no less than 50 eligible beneficiaries inside the BJC ACO community, 112 met the person aim of offering AWVs to no less than 50% of eligible sufferers inside the supplier’s affected person panel. This equates to a complete of 86.7% of suppliers assembly the established goal.


As a result of the general fee of AWVs has been growing on the nationwide stage from the inception of the AWV by way of 2017, it’s tough to establish the portion of the year-over-year improve in AWVs throughout BJC that’s attributable to the interventions mentioned on this article. Nonetheless, the magnitude of the rise (an absolute improve of 27% in AWV charges, or a relative year-over-year improve of 63%) means that the improvements had been related to advantages. Related efforts to extend AWV charges at Bellin Well being Companions yielded a rise from 43% of ACO-aligned beneficiaries having an AWV to 58% within the first 12 months following the implementation of its improvements, and an extra improve to 68% within the second 12 months.11

BJC didn’t specify which supplier wanted to conduct the AWV; thus, AWVs could have been carried out by physicians, nurse practitioners, or doctor assistants. Moreover, completely different parts of the AWVs could have been performed by completely different members of the staff.

Though AWVs are designed to handle preventive well being and in concept ought to yield advantages within the setting of satisfactory time horizons, the general utility of well-visit checkups in lowering mortality and bettering outcomes has not been definitively demonstrated21 and has lengthy been a topic of debate. One other research analyzing the affiliation of the AWV with well being care high quality, prices, and utilization demonstrated price reductions related to the AWV and advised that the best reductions in prices had been achieved within the highest-risk section of the inhabitants (utilizing affected person HCC calculations for threat stratification).9 This will likely recommend that the allocation of assets towards higher-risk sufferers could yield proportionally higher returns on funding. Sadly, practices caring for higher-risk sufferers provide fewer AWVs, probably as a consequence of useful resource limitations.14 Utilization of the AWV has additionally been proven to range by ethnoracial group (which the pertinent research outlined because the social identification of a beneficiary primarily based on their ethnicity, social background, and tradition), with disparities largely defined by variations in earnings and training.22,23


Up to now, there have been few peer-reviewed research which have explored the associations of the AWV with price financial savings. Current research have analyzed price impacts over a time horizon of not more than 24 months. Given the character of the preventive measures included within the AWV, longer time frames could also be essential to extra adequately consider the influence of the AWV on price reductions and enhancements in outcomes.

Moreover, as AWV charges are slowly growing nationwide, a portion of the will increase in AWVs could also be attributable to exterior elements favoring the adoption of AWVs unbiased of the interventions adopted.

The identification and implementation of the AWV initiative required time and assets; though BJC did obtain its AWV aim, it’s tough to evaluate whether or not the related give attention to preventive well being and elevated income has, to this point, in the end offered worth in step with the magnitude of the funding. This query could also be higher assessed as subsequent years display the sturdiness of the enhancements seen in AWV charges. If sufferers and suppliers understand the AWV to be beneficial and the efforts of BJC to lower boundaries to conducting the AWV are properly acquired, AWV charges will stay excessive and the will increase in income will proceed to yield returns on the up-front investments.

Lastly, BJC didn’t conduct formal information assortment to immediately assess affected person or supplier satisfaction with AWVs and the adjustments mentioned herein. Accordingly, though the improvements had been related to a short-term improve within the fee of AWVs amongst eligible sufferers, impacts on affected person views and patient-provider relationships can’t be assessed presently.

Future Instructions

Given the demonstration of the potential for the AWV to scale back well being care spending for higher-risk sufferers, each sufferers and practices could profit from the appliance of assets towards addressing boundaries which will forestall sufferers (particularly those that are older and frailer) from attending their AWV, together with transportation and technological options. Earlier affiliation between HCC rating and the magnitude of price profit from AWVs highlights the significance of continuous to observe prices and high quality measures for sufferers within the coming years. Future information could recommend that AWVs could also be significantly vital for a sure subset of sufferers, and higher assets and incentives could also be devoted to delivering AWVs to these sufferers who stand to derive the best profit.

Given {that a} bodily examination will not be required for completion of an AWV, a telehealth go to could also be an efficient means of administering the go to. Sufferers could possibly be offered blood strain cuffs and scales, as vital, to facilitate the physique mass index calculation and blood strain measurement required by an AWV. Some suppliers are already conducting AWVs through telehealth; extra consideration could also be given to this risk pending additional steering from CMS, particularly as telehealth options proceed to achieve traction amongst sufferers and suppliers.

Assessing affected person views and satisfaction may present beneficial perception. Affected person satisfaction scores could possibly be in comparison with assess whether or not sure facets of the AWV are related to higher satisfaction; for instance, whether or not mode of supply (in individual or telehealth), the supplier conducting the go to (eg, nurse, pharmacist, doctor), size of go to, or whether or not the affected person is co-billed for acute issues could have an effect on the affected person’s perspective and perceived utility of the AWV.


ACOs attempt to supply sufferers with the correct care on the proper time whereas lowering pointless prices and companies. AWVs characterize great alternatives for ACOs to maneuver towards assembly these goals for sufferers. Efforts by BJC to extend the uptake of AWVs centered broadly on growing the convenience of scheduling AWVs and bettering the effectivity and comfort of conducting an AWV. These efforts included elevated communication, organizational assist, and technological improvements, and so they had been related to important will increase in AWVs within the first 12 months following implementation. Within the coming years, BJC will proceed to observe AWV charges to guage the sturdiness of the enhancements from the applied adjustments and search to evaluate results on prices and the standard of care related to the supply of the AWV.


The authors are tremendously grateful for the contributions of Nancy Patterson, Ashley Barton, Ryan Soluade, Ly Mettlach, Sunil Sinha, and Doug Pogue, with out whose diligence and efforts the work offered herein wouldn’t have been doable.

Writer Affiliations: BJC Healthcare Accountable Care Group (NM, KS, JH, MG), St Louis, MO; Washington College College of Drugs in St Louis and Barnes-Jewish Hospital (NK), St Louis, MO.

Supply of Funding: None.

Writer Disclosures: The authors report no relationship or monetary curiosity with any entity that might pose a battle of curiosity with the subject material of this text.

Authorship Data: Idea and design (NM, NK, KS, JH, MG); acquisition of information (NK, KS, JH); evaluation and interpretation of information (NM); drafting of the manuscript (NM, NK); vital revision of the manuscript for vital mental content material (NM); administrative, technical, or logistic assist (KS, JH, MG); and supervision (NM, MG).

Ship Correspondence to: Nathan Moore, MD, BJC Healthcare Accountable Care Group, 670 Mason Ridge Heart Dr, Ste 300, St Louis, MO 63141. E mail: [email protected]


1. Colburn JL, Nothelle S. The Medicare annual wellness go to. Clin Geriatr Med. 2018;34(1):1-10. doi:10.1016/j.cger.2017.09.001

2. Cuenca AE, Kapsner S. Medicare wellness visits: reassessing their worth to your sufferers and your follow. Fam Pract Manag. 2019;26(2):25-30.

3. Ganguli I, Souza J, McWilliams JM, Mehrotra A. Affiliation of Medicare’s annual wellness go to with most cancers screening, referrals, utilization, and spending. Well being Aff (Millwood). 2019;38(11):1927-1935. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2019.00304

4. Jiang M, Hughes DR, Wang W. The impact of Medicare’s annual wellness go to on preventive take care of the aged. Prev Med. 2018;116:126-133. doi:10.1016/j.ypmed.2018.08.035

5. Fowler NR, Campbell NL, Pohl GM, et al. One-year impact of the Medicare annual wellness go to on detection of cognitive impairment: a cohort research. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2018;66(5):969-975. doi:10.1111/jgs.15330

6. Shen AK, Warnock R, Kelman JA. Driving immunization by way of the Medicare annual wellness go to: a rising alternative. Vaccine. 2017;35(50):6938-6940. doi:10.1016/

7. Tao G. Utilization sample of different preventive companies in the course of the US Medicare annual wellness go to. Prev Med Rep. 2017;10:210-211. doi:10.1016/j.pmedr.2017.12.014

8. Pfoh E, Mojtabai R, Bailey J, Weiner JP, Dy SM. Affect of Medicare annual wellness visits on uptake of despair screening. Psychiatr Serv. 2015;66(11):1207-1212. doi:10.1176/

9. Beckman AL, Becerra AZ, Marcus A, et al. Medicare annual wellness go to affiliation with healthcare high quality and prices. Am J Manag Care. 2019;25(3):e76-e82.

10. Misra A, Lloyd JT. Hospital utilization and expenditures amongst a nationally consultant pattern of Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries 2 years after receipt of an annual wellness go to. Prev Med. 2019;129:105850. doi:10.1016/

11. Graves N. The evolution of annual wellness visits at Bellin Well being Companions subsequent era accountable care group. CMS Innovation Heart. Might 2018. Accessed August 31, 2020.

12. Ganguli I, Souza J, McWilliams JM, Mehrotra A. Tendencies in use of the US Medicare annual wellness go to, 2011-2014. JAMA. 2017;317(21):2233-2235. doi:10.1001/jama.2017.4342

13. Search the Doctor Price Schedule. CMS. Accessed September 1, 2020.

14. Ganguli I, Souza J, McWilliams JM, Mehrotra A. Practices caring for the underserved are much less prone to undertake Medicare’s annual wellness go to. Well being Aff (Millwood). 2018;37(2):283-291. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2017.1130

15. Feifer R, Torontow J, Shah Okay, Fields R. Leveraging annual wellness visits to drive ACO efficiency. Offered at: NAACOS Fall 2019 Convention; September 27, 2019; Washington, DC.

16. Medicare Shared Financial savings Program: high quality measure benchmarks for the 2018 reporting 12 months: steering doc. CMS. July 2019. Accessed September 1, 2020.

17. Powers BW, Mostashari F, Maxson E, Lynch Okay, Navathe AS. Partaking small unbiased practices in value-based fee: constructing Aledade’s Medicare ACOs. Healthc (Amst). 2018;6(1):79-87. doi:10.1016/j.hjdsi.2017.06.003

18. Bluestein D, Diduk-Smith R, Jordan L, Persaud Okay, Hughes T. Medicare annual wellness visits: how you can get sufferers and physicians on board. Fam Pract Manag. 2017;24(2):12-16.

19. Dexheimer JW, Talbot TR, Sanders DL, Rosenbloom ST, Aronsky D. Prompting clinicians about preventive care measures: a scientific evaluate of randomized managed trials. J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2008;15(3):311-320. doi:10.1197/jamia.M2555

20. Hollmann P. The Medicare annual wellness go to: challenges and alternatives in follow. Public Coverage Growing old Rep. 2018;29(1):5-7. doi:10.1093/ppar/pry049

21. Krogsbøll LT, Jørgensen KJ, Gøtzsche PC. Common well being checks in adults for lowering morbidity and mortality from illness. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2019;1(1):CD009009. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD009009.pub3

22. Lind KE, Hildreth Okay, Lindrooth R, Crane LA, Morrato E, Perraillon MC. Ethnoracial disparities in Medicare annual wellness go to utilization: proof from a nationally consultant database. Med Care. 2018;56(9):761-766. doi:10.1097/MLR.0000000000000962

23. Lind KE, Hildreth KL, Perraillon MC. Persistent disparities in Medicare’s annual wellness go to utilization. Med Care. 2019;57(12):984-989. doi:10.1097/MLR.0000000000001229

Source link

Skip to content